Should You Get a Dog From a Breeder or a Rescue?

Should You Get a Dog From a Breeder or a Rescue?

For anyone considering bringing a dog into their life (whether it’s your very first pup or your fifth), there’s always a big question to answer: should you go to a breeder or adopt a rescue dog? Both options come with their own pros and cons, and ultimately it depends on what’s best for you, your family, and your future furry friend.

If you’re thinking about adopting from a local animal shelter or rescue group, it’s important to do your research and ask yourself honestly: is a rescue dog right for me?

The Benefits of a Rescue Dog

There are countless reasons why rescuing a dog can be one of the most rewarding decisions you’ll ever make. For starters, you’re giving a pup a second chance at life after they’ve been abandoned, surrendered, or found as a stray. Dogs thrive on companionship, and life in a shelter is never easy, by adopting, you’re giving them the loving home they desperately want.

Many rescue dogs are already adults and often come with some training, which can make things much easier compared to raising a puppy from scratch.

Helping a dog through difficult times is also incredibly rewarding. If they’ve experienced trauma or have behavioral quirks, the journey of helping them adjust and feel safe can be life-changing for both of you. And if you fall in love with a dog who has a health issue, don’t let that discourage you, many rescues and shelters will help cover some or all of the medical costs for life.

When you pay an adoption fee, it usually includes essentials like:

  • Vaccinations
  • Microchipping
  • Spaying/neutering
  • Flea and tick treatment
  • Deworming
  • Veterinary check-up
  • Temporary pet insurance (varies by shelter)

Because most rescue dogs are already spayed or neutered, you’ll save on that cost, and it can often mean a calmer, more settled pet.

The Downsides

There aren’t many negatives to adopting, but it’s important to be realistic. Some rescue dogs may not be fully trained, and others may have behavioral challenges due to their past. Training and building trust can take time, patience, and consistency.

Before committing, make sure you’re prepared for the responsibility and avoid adopting a dog whose needs you’re unable to meet. Being rehomed again can be incredibly stressful for a dog.

Choosing the Right Dog

With so many dogs in shelters waiting for homes, the hardest part is often choosing. How do you even narrow it down?

Start by making a list of what you’re looking for in your new companion.

For example:

  • Age
  • Sex
  • Breed (or mixed breed)
  • Size
  • Energy level
  • Compatibility with kids/dogs/cats
  • Coat type

Once you have a list, you can browse online adoption sites or visit shelters in person. Many rescue organizations let you filter available dogs online by age, size, or temperament, which helps you focus your search.

When visiting a shelter, you’ll usually be able to spend time with the dog, ask staff questions, play with them, and even take them for a walk. If a dog doesn’t feel like the right fit, don’t feel guilty — the shelter staff want to ensure every dog finds the perfect home. Another family will be just right for that pup.

When you do find “the one,” the process usually involves a home check, adoption paperwork, and an adoption fee. Before you know it, your new best friend will be heading home with you.

Is a Rescue Dog Right for You?

If you have the time, patience, and love to give, adopting a rescue dog can be the most rewarding choice. Yes, some may need extra training or ongoing support, but the bond you build will be unmatched.

Many people even go on to volunteer with their local shelter after experiencing the joy of rescuing a dog — it’s that life-changing!

Some of the best-known nationwide organisations include:

  • ASPCA (American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals)
  • Humane Society of the United States
  • Best Friends Animal Society

And of course, there are countless local rescues and shelters across the country waiting to introduce you to your new best friend.

Whether you choose a rescue pup or go through a breeder, the most important thing is providing a loving, safe, and happy home. But if your heart is leaning toward rescue, you’ll not only be gaining a loyal companion — you’ll also be saving a life.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.